Craigslist has no ranking. Angi and Thumbtack charge a membership and per-lead fees stacked on top.
| Craigslist | Angi / Thumbtack | The Short List | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who it's for | Mostly consumers | Homeowners | Small businesses |
| Ranking | None — flat list | Algorithmic, shared to 3–8 pros | Proximity + trust, exclusive |
| What providers pay | $5–10 per post, no listing | $25–42/mo membership + $15–100+ per lead | $20/mo flat — nothing else, ever |
| What requesters pay | Varies by post type | Nothing, but leads are shared to rivals | Always free |
| Lead sharing | N/A | Sold to several competitors at once | One introduction, one business |
| Trust layer | None | Reviews + background check | Reviews + verified neighborhood network |